September 2021 A.D.
Martin Luther’s Large Catechism
The First Commandment
Pastors’ Study Group, Faith, Plano, TX, by Rev. Clint Stark, St. John of Frisco, TX
(Revised and clipped for SJLC newsletter)
With the assumption that a thorough introduction to the Large Catechism (LC) was done last month, I won’t rehash the events leading up to the writing of the LC. I have included at the end of this paper a lengthy resource, which I find to be a great summary of the development of Christian Catechisms through the ages, including Luther’s LC. Here are a few bullet points that pertain to my narrow cause of going through the first chief part:
– Luther’s ordering of the chief parts differ from medieval catechisms, likely due to his proper understanding of Law and Gospel, including the three uses of the Law and a rejection of works- righteousness.
– Luther saw the first 3 chief parts (The 10 Commandments, Apostles’ Creed, and the Lord’s Prayer) as the most important part of the LC, which is why they are first. They could be summarized as: what we are to do and not do, what we are to believe, and how we are to pray. But a better summary might be: summary of the Law, summary/content of the Gospel, and the fruit(s) of faith, prayer.
– Luther’s numbering of the commandments differs from other catechisms.
– Luther’s Q & A format was also different than medieval catechisms.
– Luther had already preached about 30 sermons on the 10 Commandments prior to writing the LC, which shines forth in the LC. In fact, Luther’s LC is “different than a lot of reformed catechisms in that it has warmth and daily application, rather than a cold presentation of dogma.”
– The 10 Commandments are the longest chief part, and the First Commandment is the longest commandment.
Let’s read through the first part of the first chief part and ever remain a pupil of the Holy Spirit, because the LC is the teaching of Scripture. (I have also interspersed some commentary and discussion questions.) As we begin, notice that Luther doesn’t give a long introduction to the historical context of the giving of the commandments, but goes to the heart of the commandment(s), which apply universally to all mankind. (Ibid)
Thou shalt have no other gods before Me.
1] That is: Thou shalt have [and worship] Me alone as thy God. What is the force of this, and how is it to be understood? What does it mean to have a god? or, what is God? 2] Answer: A god means that from which we are to expect all good and to which we are to take refuge in all distress, so that to have a God is nothing else than to trust and believe Him from the [whole] heart; as I have often said that the confidence and faith of the heart alone make both God and an idol. 3] If your faith and trust be right, then is your god also true; and, on the other hand, if your trust be false and wrong, then you have not the true God; for these two belong together, faith and God. That now, I say, upon which you set your heart and put your trust is properly your god.
4] Therefore it is the intent of this commandment to require true faith and trust of the heart which settles upon the only true God, and clings to Him alone. That is as much as to say: “See to it that you let Me alone be your God, and never seek another,” i.e.: Whatever you lack of good things, expect it of Me, and look to Me for it, and whenever you suffer misfortune and distress, creep and cling to Me. I, yes, I, will give you enough and help you out of every need; only let not your heart cleave to or rest in any other.
What a beautiful and simple summary. There is no room for only an outward pharisaical keeping of this commandment. And there is no room for just trying your hardest. There is no wiggle room with, “your whole heart.”
5] This I must unfold somewhat more plainly, that it may be understood and perceived by ordinary examples of the contrary. Many a one thinks that he has God and everything in abundance when he has money and, possessions; he trusts in them and boasts of them with such firmness and assurance as to care for no one. 6] Lo, such a man also has a god, Mammon by name, i.e., money and possessions, on which he sets all his heart, and which is also the most common idol on earth. 7] He who has money and possessions feels secure, and is joyful and undismayed as though he were sitting in the midst of Paradise. 8] On the other hand, he who has none doubts and is despondent, as though he knew of no God. 9] For very few are to be found who are of good cheer, and who neither mourn nor complain if they have not Mammon. This [care and desire for money] sticks and clings to our nature, even to the grave.
10] So, too, whoever trusts and boasts that he possesses great skill, prudence, power, favor, friendship, and honor has also a god, but not this true and only God. This appears again when you notice how presumptuous, secure, and proud people are because of such possessions, and how despondent when they no longer exist or are withdrawn. Therefore I repeat that the chief explanation of this point is that to have a god is to have something in which the heart entirely trusts.
Notice how much good theology he puts into so few words: It’s a summary of the theology of glory, which leads to self-righteousness or despair. And, he properly confesses original sin and the simul doctrine, “sticks and clings to our nature, even to the grave”. This stands against Rome’s teaching and all the holiness movements then and now, e.g. Pelagianism, Pentecostalism, Methodism, etc. As an aside, what other sects or church bodies, then and now, hold a proper view of original sin? Calvinism?
I’d say the above is a general summary of the universal application of this commandment, with universal ways to have other gods mentioned in scripture, e.g. mammon. This next section focuses on some specific abuses of the day.
11] Besides, consider what, in our blindness, we have hitherto been practicing and doing under the Papacy. If any one had a toothache, he fasted and honored St. Apollonia [macerated his flesh by voluntary fasting to the honor of St. Apollonia]; if he was afraid of fire, he chose St. Lawrence as his helper in need; if he dreaded pestilence, he made a vow to St. Sebastian or Rochio, and a countless number of such abominations, where every one selected his own saint, worshiped him, and called for help to him in distress.
Sadly, the Roman Catholic Church still practices this form of idolatry. (Over the years, the tradition arose of St. Joseph having a special power in real estate transactions. European nuns buried a medal with his likeness on property they hoped to aquire for convents. Gradually the medals were replaced with statues and the focus changed from buying to selling. The statue is buried upside down in the front yard with the feet pointing to heaven. It may face toward the home (or toward the street if you want your neighbor’s home to sell!) The location of the statue can vary: by the “For Sale” sign, in a flower pot (popular for condo owners), etc.. As long as you can find it once the home has sold. After the home has sold, the statue should be removed from the ground and given a place of honor in your new home.)
12] Here belong those also, as, e. g., sorcerers and magicians, whose idolatry is most gross, and who make a covenant with the devil, in order that he may give them plenty of money or help them in love-affairs, preserve their cattle, restore to them lost possessions, etc. For all these place their heart and trust elsewhere than in the true God, look for nothing good to Him nor seek it from Him.
Nothing new under the sun. Many men sell their souls to the devil and fall for his temptations that our brother, Jesus, faced and defeated. May our Lord keep us from becoming Faustus and keep us steadfast in His Word.
13] Thus you can easily understand what and how much this commandment requires, namely, that man’s entire heart and all his confidence be placed in God alone, and in no one else. For to have God, you can easily perceive, it is not to lay hold of Him with our hands or to put Him in a bag [as money], or to lock Him in a chest [as silver vessels]. 14] But to apprehend Him means when the heart lays hold of Him and clings to Him. 15] But to cling to Him with the heart is nothing else than to trust in Him entirely. For this reason He wishes to turn us away from everything else that exists outside of Him, and to draw us to Himself, namely, because He is the only eternal good. As though He would say; Whatever you have heretofore sought of the saints, or for whatever [things] you have trusted in Mammon or anything else, expect it all of Me, and regard Me as the one who will help you and pour out upon you richly all good things.
Luther is back to the heart of the matter (see my emphases above). While this could be classified as “second use” of the Law, you also see a wonderful invitation to Christians, who have the Holy Spirit, to cooperate [though in great weakness] and believe that God is good. Furthermore, doesn’t this explanation, much like the historical giving of the commandments to Moses, show that the Law of God is always good and that God’s disposition towards His people is good? Unlike a lot of soft antinomian preaching today, the Law is not bad and the Gospel good. Yes, the Law is ‘bad’ if in the formula of justification, but the Law shows God’s perfect and good will.
16] Lo, here you have the meaning of the true honor and worship of God, which pleases God, and which He commands under penalty of eternal wrath, namely, that the heart know no other comfort or confidence than in Him, and do not suffer itself to be torn from Him, but, for Him, risk and disregard everything upon earth. 17] On the other hand, you can easily see and judge how the world practises only false worship and idolatry. For no people has ever been so reprobate as not to institute and observe some divine worship; every one has set up as his special god whatever he looked to for blessings, help, and comfort.
Notice Luther defines “worship” here not as the liturgy or outward forms, etc., but as faith alone, which is true worship. For whatever is done apart from faith is sin. For a great paper on this Biblical and Confessional definition of worship as faith, click here.
18] Thus, for example, the heathen who put their trust in power and dominion elevated Jupiter as the supreme god; the others, who were bent upon riches, happiness, or pleasure, and a life of ease, Hercules, Mercury, Venus, or others; women with child, Diana or Lucina, and so on; thus every one made that his god to which his heart was inclined, so that even in the mind of the heathen to have a god means to trust and believe. 19] But their error is this, that their trust is false and wrong; for it is not placed in the only God, besides whom there is truly no God in heaven or upon earth. 20] Therefore the heathen really make their self-invented notions and dreams of God an idol, and put their trust in that which is altogether nothing. 21] Thus it is with all idolatry; for it consists not merely in erecting an image and worshiping it, but rather in the heart, which stands gaping at something else, and seeks help and consolation from creatures, saints, or devils, and neither cares for God, nor looks to Him for so much good as to believe that He is willing to help, neither believes that whatever good it experiences comes from God.
I’d summarize this as there is on true God. There really aren’t other gods just made-up gods.
22] Besides, there is also a false worship and extreme idolatry, which we have hitherto practiced, and is still prevalent in the world, upon which also all ecclesiastical orders are founded, and which concerns the conscience alone, that seeks in its own works help, consolation, and salvation, presumes to wrest heaven from God, and reckons how many bequests it has made, how often it has fasted, celebrated Mass, etc.
You can see how heresy just gets repackages: prayer chains and “forward this email to 100 people and God will…”
Upon such things it depends, and of them boasts, as though unwilling to receive anything from God as a gift, but desires itself to earn or merit it superabundantly, just as though He must serve us and were our debtor, and we His liege lords. 23] What is this but reducing God to an idol, yea, [a fig image or] an apple-god, and elevating and regarding ourselves as God? But this is slightly too subtile, and is not for young pupils.
I dislike the phrase I’m about to use because it is so abused to excuse unfaithfulness, but you do see Luther’s “pastoral heart” and his ability to teach the young and old, learned and unlearned.
24] But let this be said to the simple, that they may well note and remember the meaning of this commandment, namely, that we are to trust in God alone, and look to Him and expect from Him naught but good, as from one who gives us body, life, food, drink, nourishment, health, protection, peace, and all necessaries of both temporal and eternal things. He also preserves us from misfortune, and if any evil befall us, delivers and rescues us, so that it is God alone (as has been sufficiently said) from whom we receive all good, and by whom 25] we are delivered from all evil. Hence also, I think, we Germans from ancient times call God (more elegantly and appropriately than any other language) by that name from the word Good, as being an eternal fountain which gushes forth abundantly nothing but what is good, and from which flows forth all that is and is called good.
Very similar verbiage here as in his explanation to the First Article of The Creed. Again, what a beautiful and succinct explanation of the heart of the commandment.
26] For even though otherwise we experience much good from men, still whatever we receive by His command or arrangement is all received from God. For our parents, and all rulers, and every one besides with respect to his neighbor, have received from God the command that they should do us all manner of good, so that we receive these blessings not from them, but, through them, from God. For creatures are only the hands, channels, and means whereby God gives all things, as He gives to the mother breasts and milk to offer to her child, and corn and all manner of produce from the earth for nourishment, none of which blessings could be produced by any creature of itself.
More anti-deism langue–also in the first article, but also the proper teaching that God works through means.
27] Therefore no man should presume to take or give anything except as God has commanded, in order that it may be acknowledged as God’s gift, and thanks may be rendered Him for it, as this commandment requires. On this account also these means of receiving good gifts through creatures are not to be rejected, neither should we in presumption seek other ways and means than God has commanded. For that would not be receiving from God, but seeking of ourselves.
Maybe I’m reaching here, but might these words speak against the welfare state and gambling?
28] Let every one, then, see to it that he esteem this commandment great and high above all things, and do not regard it as a joke. Ask and examine your heart diligently, and you will find whether it cleaves to God alone or not. If you have a heart that can expect of Him nothing but what is good, especially in want and distress, and that, moreover, renounces and forsakes everything that is not God, then you have the only true God. If, on the contrary, it cleaves to anything else, of which it expects more good and help than of God, and does not take refuge in Him, but in adversity flees from Him, then you have an idol, another god.
Yes, these are serious and scary words for sinners. The Law always accuses and makes no room for the “old college try”. This also makes room, or makes ready, for the imputed righteousness of Christ.
29] In order that it may be seen that God will not have this commandment thrown to the winds, but will most strictly enforce it, He has attached to it first a terrible threat, and then a beautiful, comforting promise which is also to be urged and impressed upon young people, that they may take it to heart and retain it:
[Exposition of the Appendix to the First Commandment.]
30] For I am the Lord, thy God, strong and jealous, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate Me; and showing mercy unto thousands of them that love Me and keep My commandments.
31] Although these words relate to all the commandments (as we shall hereafter learn), yet they are joined to this chief commandment because it is of first importance that men have a right head; for where the head is right, the whole life must be right, and vice versa.
If you could keep the First you would keep the rest?
32] Learn, therefore, from these words how angry God is with those who trust in anything but Him, and again, how good and gracious He is to those who trust and believe in Him alone with the whole heart; so that His anger does not cease until the fourth generation, while, on the other hand, His blessing and goodness extend to many thousands, 33] lest you live in such security and commit yourself to chance, as men of brutal heart, who think that it makes no great difference [how they live]. 34] He is a God who will not leave it unavenged if men turn from Him, and will not cease to be angry until the fourth generation, even until they are utterly exterminated. Therefore He is to be feared, and not to be despised.
35] He has also demonstrated this in all history, as the Scriptures abundantly show and daily experience still teaches. For from the beginning He has utterly extirpated all idolatry, and, on account of it, both heathen and Jews; even as at the present day He overthrows all false worship, so that all who remain therein must finally perish. 36] Therefore, although proud, powerful, and rich worldlings [Sardanapaluses and Phalarides, King of Syria 600 B.C. and Greek tyrant 570 B.C.] who surpass even the Persians in wealth] are now to be found, who boast defiantly of their Mammon, with utter disregard whether God is angry at or smiles on them, and dare to withstand His wrath, yet they shall not succeed, but before they are aware, they shall be wrecked, with all in which they trusted; as all others have perished who have thought themselves more secure or powerful.
As the great road scholar, Earl Pitts, pontificates, “Wake up, America!”
37] And just because of such hardened heads who imagine because God connives and allows them to rest in security, that He either is entirely ignorant or cares nothing about such matters, He must deal a smashing blow and punish them, so that He cannot forget it unto children’s children; so that every one may take note and see that this is no joke to Him. 38] For they are those whom He means when He says: Who hate Me, i.e., those who persist in their defiance and pride; whatever is preached or said to them, they will not listen; when they are reproved, in order that they may learn to know themselves and amend before the punishment begins, they become mad and foolish so as to fairly merit wrath, as now we see daily in bishops and princes.
Though not in these terms, I’d say the above distinguishes between mortal and venial sins or sins of weakens and sins of dominance. While certainly this could include an unbeliever like Pharaoh, I’d say it could also apply to a Christian falling away, like David, who is cited in our Confessions. Might this also show “sinning against better knowledge vs mostly ignorance”? (“Mostly” because the law is written on the heart and all are without excuse. Romans 1.)
39] But terrible as are these threatenings, so much the more powerful is the consolation in the promise, that those who cling to God alone should be sure that He will show them mercy, that is, show them pure goodness and blessing, not only for themselves, but also to their children and children’s children, even to the thousandth generation and beyond that. 40] This ought certainly to move and impel us to risk our hearts in all confidence with God, if we wish all temporal and eternal good, since the Supreme Majesty makes such sublime offers and presents such cordial inducements and such rich promises.
41] Therefore let every one seriously take this to heart, lest it be regarded as though a man had spoken it. For to you it is a question either of eternal blessing, happiness, and salvation, or of eternal wrath, misery, and woe. What more would you have or desire than that He so kindly promises to be yours with every blessing, and to protect and help you in all need?
I’d say Luther doesn’t over explain here, but allows God’s “close of the commandments” to speak.
42] But, alas! here is the failure, that the world believes nothing of this, nor regards it as God’s Word because it sees that those who trust in God and not in Mammon suffer care and want, and the devil opposes and resists them, that they have neither money, favor, nor honor, and, besides, can scarcely support life; while, on the other hand, those who serve Mammon have power, favor, honor, possessions, and every comfort in the eyes of the world. For this reason, these words must be grasped as being directed against such appearances; and we must consider that they do not lie or deceive, but must come true.
Theology of the cross. & Now, but not yet theology.
43] Reflect for yourself or make inquiry and tell me: Those who have employed all their care and diligence to accumulate great possessions and wealth, what have they finally attained? You will find that they have wasted their toil and labor, or even though they have amassed great treasures, they have been dispersed and scattered, so that they themselves have never found happiness in their wealth, and afterwards it never reached the third generation.
Pious opinion and quia subscription: I know Luther goes on to cite examples to support his assertions, but can’t we think of dynasties and rich families that go beyond the third generation? Could this be taken in a less literal earthly way and be applied to mean on the Last Day they have attained nothing? Also, I know rich unbelievers, who seem happy. Does he mean, true biblical joy? What is the German for happy?
44] Instances of this you will find a plenty in all histories, also in the memory of aged and experienced people. Only observe and ponder them.
45] Saul was a great king, chosen of God, and a godly man; but when he was established on his throne, and let his heart decline from God, and put his trust in his crown and power, he had to perish with all that he had, so that none even of his children remained.
46] David, on the other hand, was a poor, despised man, hunted down and chased, so that he nowhere felt secure of his life; yet he had to remain in spite of Saul, and become king. For these words had to abide and come true, since God cannot lie or deceive. Only let not the devil and the world deceive you with their show, which indeed remains for a time, but finally is nothing.
Yes, this would be a specific promise to David, but not a universal promise to all, right? What I mean is, the world and her wealth will come to nothing at some point, but not necessarily at the third generation.
47] Let us, then, learn well the First Commandment, that we may see how God will tolerate no presumption nor any trust in any other object, and how He requires nothing higher of us than confidence from the heart for everything good, so that we may proceed right and straightforward and use all the blessings which God gives no farther than as a shoemaker uses his needle, awl, and thread for work, and then lays them aside, or as a traveler uses an inn, and food, and his bed only for temporal necessity, each one in his station, according to God’s order, and without allowing any of these things to be our lord or idol. 48] Let this suffice with respect to the First Commandment, which we have had to explain at length, since it is of chief importance, because, as before said, where the heart is rightly disposed toward God and this commandment is observed, all the others follow.
Again, what do you all think of teaching the First Commandment like this: “If you could keep the first commandment you would keep the rest?” Also, a great summary, again, plus, a nice explanation of faith producing good works in our vocations.
by Mary Jane Haemig Original in English, displayed in English▾ Published: 2014-07-28
Share this Post